Todd.
Thanks to your mother for many hours of delightful reading. I have just finished rereading most of the Pern series and wish to share the following observations. As a long time science fiction reader, a former graduate student in applied anthropology and a retired state policy and budget analyst, I have thoroughly enjoyed most of her books. I was however struck with the question that kept being raised in The Skies of Pern, regarding what the dragon riders would do after the thread ceased to fall. I recently taught a graduate class in international development and see the Weyrs continuing to play a critical role in the political and economic infrastructure of the planet. They would of course have to provide much of their own food, but could charge enough for their services to cover their other needs.
Pern has a planetary government in which the Weyrs are critical. Without dragons the Lord Holders, Craftmasters and Weyr leaders could not meet in any practical manner to address ongoing problems of a developing planet, such as, Pern. The dragon riders have in the various books proved to be critical to dealing with natural disasters, enforcing Pern council decisions (kind of a law enforcement role), and generally maintaining communication across the entire world. If future books are written and the western and southern continents are settled, such communication, transportation, and links, that only the weyrs can provide, would be necessary to maintaining order (i.e., the rule of law essential for peace and development) throughout Pern.
I would even suggest that dragons would have been more useful that either the US navy or elephants in addressing the recent tsunami in the Indian Ocean (the Pern tsunami outlined the problem rather well). The presence of dragons and fire lizards in today’s Congo would significantly transform that problem, probably for the better. But that thought focuses on a problem, poorly addressed by most science fiction writers, of transporting and reestablishing earth technology on a colony planet. Almost any piece of current technology depends on a huge pyramid of multiple technologies, manufacturing facilities, and knowledge bases, which are likely to be difficult to transport in any kind of star ship and reconstruct on a challenging planet within any reasonable timeframe.
Pern dragons and fire lizards could be essential to colonists, particularly during their first few generations on a new planet. They would make an interesting addition to any survey teams exploring new planets, as long as they could live off the land. Most science fiction survey teams seem to have an almost unlimited supply of fuel, allowing them considerable exploration time. Dragons and fire lizards would give them more flexibility. If dragons could mind merge with any of the Lyon descendents, then additional possibilities present themselves, along with solving the problem of dragons having to spend any significant time in transport ships. I see an almost unlimited potential for stories should Pern be rediscovered, after thread fall disappears and Pern has readjusted to dragon riders assuming critical roles. Fire lizards could also evolve more useful and interesting traits as generations of fire lizards co-exist with men on multiple planets, habitats, and ships.
Jules
Hi Jules!
Ahem, your analysis smacks of suggesting new stories but I’ll forgive you.
I’m afraid that for me you’ve said nothing that hasn’t already been thought of and discussed in some detail (dinner at Dragonhold can get quite interesting).
I’d quibble with you about the role of the Weyrs and remind you of the role of the Harpers.
However, to get a really good feel for Pern, you need to remember its roots. The roots of the stories are firmly set in the skies over Britain when the RAF fought boldly for survival against the Luftwaffe. Mum has recast the story of “the few” into a world where there is no enemy to hate, only an enemy to destroy (Thread). Mum was fourteen when the Battle of Britain occured and it clearly left an impression (pardon the pun) on her.
If you accept that dragons are analogous to the fighters of the RAF in the Battle of Britain, you can logically extend projections to their activities in a postwar or post-Thread period. You’ll get mail carriers, airlines, airline bankruptcies, et cetera.
I don’t think you’ll get good stories if you take the dragons off Pern. I think the heart of the stories is that background of fighting again and again the near-hopeless battle against an implacable foe, of risking everything — even your very soul — to save the planet and the people you love.
Also, Mum has made it very clear that she wants to keep her universes separate. There won’t be dragons meeting Talents in the Tower — those are two separate universes. I think she’s right in doing so — trying to build a grand-unified McCaffrey would only cheapen the strengths of the individual series.
Cheers,
Todd